How I Lost $1,400 Today and Why That's Okay

Kraig | April 15, 2013 | 13 Comments · Learning New Things, Getting Ahead
I lost $1,418.71 today. The stock market took a plunge, it's biggest drop in six months. Since then, it's been going up like crazy. I've sure loved the value that's been added to my portfolio of mutual funds, but lately, it's been tough for me to justify buying any more shares, knowing that the stock market is at an all time high.

Now, I don't pretend to be an expert investor. I just started investing last fall, right before the presidential election. The market had been headed north for a few years at that point, in which I missed out on its gains. After making up my mind that I wasn't going to be buying anything with my fairly large savings account, I decided to start investing. Being a follower of Mr. Money Mustache and Jim Collins of jlcollinsnh, I started to buy into the whole idea of index investing. I even read the book, A Random Walk Down Wall Street, to further my knowledge of this strategy. Whether or not index funds are the best way to go, I'm not here to give advice on. Some would say that picking individual stocks is a better idea. Others, like my friend Jason from DividendMantra.com, would argue that dividend growth investing is the best way to go. Hey, whatever floats your boat. I think those strategies are pretty rad. But, I am a believer in the strategy I'm taking, which is investing in index funds. The path I've chosen is at the recommendation of Jim Collins of jlcollinsnh. He has a stock series on his blog that I have to admit, was the single biggest help I had in learning what to do with my growing savings account. Jim laid it all out there and set the expectation with me that the market goes up and down, sometimes in huge amounts. He says if you're going to invest in stocks, you should invest for the long haul and STAY THE COURSE if you want to grow your wealth and not lose your rear end. So after reading his series and thinking hard about my risk tolerance, I took a look at myself, my spot in life and decided that I could handle it and stay the course if things got rough. Things have been real cushy in the past 6 months that I've been investing. The market is up over 10% since I opened my Vanguard account and started shifting money over to it. I've seen an increase in the value of my assets of over $5,000 in that time frame. It's been quite exciting. I've read that I should always use caution when trying to time the market, or in other words, trying to use price fluctuations to my advantage. Many argue that this can't be done effectively by the majority of people, over the long term. I'm not sure what my stance is on this quite yet. Here's my strategy on it all. I like to follow Jim, as I believe he knows what he's talking about, but I also like to follow Warren Buffet, who OBVIOUSLY knows his stuff. Here's the quote that I do my investing by:

"Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful."

And so, I've bought on the down days. I have not sold, because I am a long term investor, in it for the long haul. I plan to continue to build my portfolio out until the day that I'm financially independent. Even after that, I don't ever plan to sell assets at a higher rate than they will be growing at. I plan to be a long term investor, never really decreasing my portfolio's value over the long term. Back to Warren's quote. I think he's dead on. As noted in the book "A Random Walk Down Wall Street" and in Jim Collins' stock series, the market fluctuates like mad. However, it always goes up over the long term. Why does it fluctuate? Because people speculate like crazy. When the media tells the whole country that a "fiscal cliff" is approaching, people panic and sell their stock, because they think the market will tank. The same thing happens with a presidential election, where emotions go wild. Right after the election, people freaked out. I believe they thought that Obama would wreck the economy with his spending plans. The market took a dip after his election. I bought stock. Then at the end of the year, the news scared the crap out of everyone with worries of a "fiscal cliff" approaching if congress didn't come to a deal. Investors panicked and sold a bunch of shares, causing the market to drop. I bought more shares. And today, with worries over China's economy, the market took it's biggest dip since last November. Shares of VTSAX, the stock I own, which is the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index fund, dropped $1.00 per share. I own 1,418 of them so I lost $1,418 today. Some would say ouch, but what did I do? I bought another $5,000 worth of shares today. I'm in a great cash position and I believe that the market is being fearful right now, which means it's my turn to be greedy. Am I scared? No, because I have a bunch of additional capital sitting in the bank that I can buy more VTSAX shares with at a discount, if the market keeps dropping. I'm all about buying cheap stock, so bring it on stock market. Keep going down, I dare you. It's pretty great when you can lose $1,400 and not have to worry about it. That just means that you're investing a ton of money and you're that much closer to reaching financial independence. If you aren't willing to take the hits of a drop in the stock market, you won't be set up to ride the growth of it when it takes off.

Enjoyed this? Get new posts by email.

Join the Young Cheap Living newsletter — thoughtful essays on living cheap so you can do things that matter. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

13 Comments

  • April 15, 2013 at 7:48 PM

    I try to not get concerned with market drops or too happy when it goes up. I try to think long term and my portfolio has trended upwardly for quite a while although some stocks or funds go up and down.

    krantcents avatar
    • Kraig @ Young Cheap Living says:
      April 15, 2013 at 7:53 PM

      KC, I try to do the same, but sometimes, it's hard to ignore a big change, either up or down. But yes, I'm in it for the long haul too. In my opinion, that's the best way to do it.

      Kraig @ Young Cheap Living avatar
      • April 16, 2013 at 9:14 AM

        Haha, imagine if you had $1 million or more in the stock market on a day it declines by 2% ;-) This is why I invest for dividends - on the day of the 2% decline, my holding Procter & Gamble (PG) boosted dividends by 7%. My dividend income is going up, which is why I can afford to ignore the day to day fluctuations in my portfolio. Anywhere I look, everyone is holding back on buying stocks. This shows you that people are still fearful, rather than greedy.

        Dividend Growth Investor avatar
  • April 15, 2013 at 7:59 PM

    If I weren't so hard-core into DCAing I would have bought on a day like today. I have noticed, though, that since I consume so much financial information through the news and PF blogs I really have a hard time telling when "others" are being fearful or greedy. It seems that whenever something extreme happens one faction goes one way another faction goes the other way, following the advice! But I can't tell who moved first and who is trying to take advantage or whatever, so I just keep DCAing. :)

    Emily @ evolvingPF avatar
    • CashRebel says:
      April 15, 2013 at 9:30 PM

      I guess I'm somewhere in between you (Kraig) and Emily on this one. I love DCAing, for obvious reasons, but I've got a huge cash reserve that I'd love to get into the market if things start to crash for reals. That being said, I don't actually think it matters. The thesis of Jim Collin's stock series is really that no one can predict the market, and DCAing will always be your best bet. BTW, I LOVE the titel of this post.

      CashRebel avatar
  • April 15, 2013 at 8:10 PM

    Kraig, Great job keeping your eye on the long-term and being greedy when others are fearful. I couldn't agree more......since I also put fresh capital to work for me in the market today. I love drops like today, and look forward to more!! I think my portfolio was down about $1,700 today, but when others see red I see green. :) I, like you, hope the market goes down further. Let's keep our fingers crossed. Best wishes!

    Dividend Mantra avatar
    • Alyssa Baker says:
      April 25, 2013 at 6:42 PM

      Sometimes loosing a good sum makes me feel a bit awkward, and I am into deep thinking why I have lost such amount if I can do better, right now am into www.24option.com trading binary options and other think that this one is never a good idea but with this kind of money making scheme, I try to keep a journal of my own trade and try to learn and trade properly out of it. And through the help of my very own journal I could keep track if I am over trading or not.

      Alyssa Baker avatar
  • Wade says:
    April 16, 2013 at 9:13 AM

    I'm 41 and I've found I sleep better not owning individual stocks. To each their own, but volatility for a single stock is very high. For a sector is high as well. I buy relatively low cost mutual funds that span the different types. The hardest thing to live with lately is that everything goes down together and everything goes up together. If 2008 taught us anything it is Don't Panic. Selling on the way down is a poor strategy. Stick to your plan and buy when you were going to buy. Best to make it automatic.

    Wade avatar
  • David says:
    April 16, 2013 at 10:35 AM

    Kraig- great blog! I lost $670 yesterday on an investment I made last Friday. I have learned to play these scenarios out and wait for the market to rebound. I am currently investing in petroleum energy companies because their stocks have taken a dive.

    David avatar
  • SHP says:
    April 16, 2013 at 11:20 AM

    You may have had a unrealized loss but you don't lose (or gain) any money unless you sale.

    SHP avatar
  • cv says:
    June 1, 2013 at 8:33 PM

    I don't time anything, except as soon as my paycheck is deposited on the last day of the month, a portion of it goes automatically to vanguard. Think you can beat the system? Check out this forum http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/forum/investor-alley/it's-better-to-invest-when-the-market-is-at-a-record-high/

    cv avatar
  • ES says:
    August 6, 2013 at 9:40 AM

    Hi Kraig, Is all of your VTSAX from contributing to a roth ira/ira (annual max around $5,500) or your buying in through a brokerage fund too?

    ES avatar
    • Kraig @ Young Cheap Living says:
      August 6, 2013 at 9:42 AM

      ES, It's all in a regular brokerage account. Take care,

      Kraig @ Young Cheap Living avatar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *